Value investing message boards image Log on |  Join ($$) Stock market forums image VF "How To" Guide        Welcome, guest! Learn about guest access               Home

Whats happening in China

 << previous next >>
 > New post - to everyone
 > New post - to private group
View 2/17 Daily Digest
View Private Post Inbox
Review Tracked Comments

Tip: use ALLCAPS for symbol search
-- Advanced Search Page --
-- Comment Search Page --
 > Log on
 > What Is ValueForum?
 > Try ValueForum Today

symbol lookup » my portfolios »
Topic: International Stocks — China
Jan. 6 2016, 11:01 PM ET - by VF member bz1516 (2451 gold star (click for information on feedback))

Whats happening in China .................................................

It's important to put the current situation in context.

A 7% drop is a very serious drop because based on statistical inference if the total exchange is at -7% it means that many stocks have already reached their daily limit of -10%. This drop because it happened so early into the trading day is an historically large market crash, much steeper than 1929 or 1987.

The market in China is made up mostly of inexperienced retail investors and traders so it runs on emotion and is probably the least reflective of actual underlying business and economic conditions of any stock market in the world.

It is a cause for concern given the weakness in both their manufacturing and non manufacturing PMIs, both the official and the Caixin. It is the timing of the stock market rout and the PMIs that raises more concern with this selloff.

The increasingly rapid drop in the Yuan is an extremely important tell that the economic managers over there are circling the wagons.

The trade figures are due out in a few days. My guess is they would show even more deterioration than we have seen so far.

Also that the government made an early move to block selling by major stockholders underscores the seriousness of the crash and connects it to the PMI data and the exchange rate. All this suggests the economic problems may be much deeper than it appears from any data.

I have maintained for a while that we are in a hard landing. That has to be distinguished from both a soft landing and a crash landing or economic collapse.

We had a hard landing in late 2008 and the economic numbers were a lot worse. We had real sequential loss for one quarter. That is a long way down from 7% growth estimates.

The base case right now would be something akin to 2008, the equivalent of a moderate recession in the US. which is a big deal for a country which has not had one since its been industrialized.

Now that we have gotten this far into the hard landing and are virtually certain their economic numbers lack a grounding in reality, the door must be opened for the first time to a crash landing.

Right now the major probability is they will have a hard landing. However there is also maybe a 5% chance there will be a crash landing, that is something worse than we had in 2008.

While this is terrible for commodities and materials stocks, it will have very little effect on the US. My best estimate would be it hurts the US GDP by a maximum of ~0.3%. It will also not have a major effect on US companies overseas profits. China accounts for only a small portion of those profits, less than 10%. There is very little US bank exposure over there to the best of my knowledge.

Its possible European banks have a lot more exposure. The EU particularly Germany also has lot more exposure to foreign trade with China than we do.

All this suggests to me buy US stocks on the downside move, whenever you think the time is right.


Click To Add Your POPositive RecommendationITIVE Recommendation!   |  Currently: 
 146 positive

 << previous next >>

Looking for insight and analysis shared by fellow self directed investors? You've come to the right place! ValueForum is the web's best community forum for unvarnished, trusted, up-to-the-minute thinking on investments. What you just read is a "public post" but most posts including comments and replies, are available only to members.

Imagine walking into a secluded room where some of the smartest, most successful investors in America are gathered — self-directed investors and hedge fund managers alike — to share investing ideas.

In this private setting, members of this exclusive group are able to share honest opinions and unfiltered insights on stocks, bonds, ETFs, options, Forex and more. There's also a healthy amount of respectful debate as they bandy ideas about. And in the end, everyone is the richer for it.

That kind of exchange is exactly what happens every day here on, the Internet's premier investing community.

Membership in this private online community is strictly limited — just 1500 investors will be admitted — but today you are in line to be one of them.

Before I tell you about all the member benefits waiting for you, I want to make one thing clear: is nothing like the big free public investment boards out there.

We started so that serious investors could get away from the noise, the shills and the shouting that plague public stock message boards.

That's why our community is founded on a few simple rules that keep the quality of our content and our members very high...

  • Privacy is paramount and confidentiality strictly enforced. Members are forbidden from sharing or reposting any members-only content; violators forfeit membership.

  • Multiple aliases are not permitted (behind every screen name is a member profile so you can get to know your fellow members — and many have become lifelong friends).

  • No unsolicited or unauthorized advertising or product selling is allowed.

  • Robust debates are encouraged, but respect and common courtesy are expected with fighting and name-calling disallowed.

  • Violators forfeit membership.

And it works. As one of our long-time members explains:

"ValueForum gives you the chance to learn from people who aren't trying to sell you anything, just willing to give away their sincere thoughts. I have made a lot of money from information on VF."

So whether you are looking for new stock ideas or new ways to boost your investment income with REITs, BDCs, high-yield bonds, closed-end funds, you'll be thrilled at the constant flow of reliable ideas and analysis.

As another of our members going by the handle of oldart will tell you...

"No friend, no book, no broker, no advisor, no expert has ever provided a tenth what I am able to find here. The best money I have EVER spent is for membership."


Your membership gives you unlimited access to:

  • A steady stream of top-notch investment ideas.

  • Invaluable insights and analysis on stocks, bonds, REITs, BDCs, and more.

  • Over 100 message board topics to help you focus on the areas that interest you most.

  • The chance to share your investment ideas and have them thoroughly vetted by your ValueForum peers before you make a move.

  • The stock rating system with more than 1,000 rated stocks.

And yet another member (known on ValueForum as "beetlebomb") tells all willing to listen:
"The cost of ValueForum is a pittance compared to the benefits you will receive. If you are a serious investor who is tired of being fleeced by the Wall Street crowd, I highly recommend you join VF on a trial basis and experience its benefits first hand."

The best way to see what can do for you is to let you take it for a test drive.

That's why we're offering a special one week "guest pass" that lets you experience the full force of for just $7.

$7 for access to a new investing tool that can be truly life changing. It was for this member, who goes by "stlbeerman"

" VF has really changed my life and made me more wealthy than I ever expected."

It's lively and engaging, but like Las Vegas, what goes on inside ValueForum stays inside ValueForum — the public post you just read is the exception, not the norm. See for yourself before our remaining memberships are claimed and it's too late!

You can get started now with your seven day guest pass (just $7) if you'd like, or, grab a 3, 6, or 12 month pass here.

Get Started Now image

"Value Forum is literally the best web site on the Internet for investors bar none. It's a real time collection of news, experiences, data sharing, opinions that you can never get from bigger sites like or Motley Fool. It allows you to gather multiple opinions you can never get from speaking to a stock broker or their analysts."

As seen in:

Ranked: Forbes best of the web

"Best investment I ever made."

"I have made a lot of money from ideas exchanged on this forum. I would recommend VF to any serious investor, and I will never be without it."

Try It Now image

"Unbelievably board and deep industry knowledge."

"Our retirement has been a financial success due entirely to Value Forum."

"The very best investing board in the country whether your profile is high risk/high reward all the way to conservative/adverse to risk & volatility. This is a monitored board where civility & helpfulness rule."

Start your test drive image

Email / About | Privacy | Terms of Use | How To / FAQ | Msg Ticker | VF Home | My.vf | BDCs.vf | Energy.vf | REITs.vf | TA.vf
Nothing in is intended to be investment advice, nor does it represent the opinion of, counsel
from, or recommendations by ©2003 - 2020, Powered in part by Ticker TechnologiesContact Us

Whats happening in China