Value investing message boards image Log on |  Join ($$) Stock market forums image VF "How To" Guide        Welcome, guest! Learn about guest access                       
ValueForum.com Home

Understanding EIA Data and How to Use It Now


 << previous next >>
 Post
 > New post - to everyone
 > New post - to private group
 Search
View 2/28 Daily Digest
Launch Message Ticker
View Private Post Inbox
Review Tracked Comments

Tip: use ALLCAPS for symbol search
 Keywords:  
 Period:  
-- Advanced Search Page --
-- Comment Search Page --
 Settings
 > Log on
 > What Is ValueForum?
 > Try ValueForum Today

symbol lookup » my portfolios »
Topic: Energy — Oil
Jul. 7 2015, 1:39 PM ET - by VF member bz1516 (2358 gold star (click for information on feedback))

Understanding EIA data and how to use it now --

All the discussion and comments weíve seen recently about EIA data and its reliability finally got me to take a deep dive into it. This is an important issue because US crude supply trends will determine the investability of oil producers and oilfield service including frac sand companies in coming months. My mission focused primarily on understanding the methodology of EIA reporting particularly supply data, and once that was accomplished drawing inferences about the direction of supply and pricing in the US.

The first thing I learned, in terms of making forecasts from EIA data, is the primary documents should be the monthly supply documents. These run two months behind the latest weekly documents. The latest monthly documents were just released this week. The latest monthly document is April.

Each month there is an adjustment made to supply numbers. These adjustments are a plugged number. But not to worry. This is a sound procedure. The disposition of the crude supply is considered more reliable. So the total supply number is made to equal the more accurate disposition number. Disposition is the way crude supply is used each month with the major use being refinery input.

Weekly data is model driven. The weekly data must be considered as subject to meaningful revision. Its weekly change is probably right in order of magnitude, but nobody knows by how much.

There are other levels of adjustment as well. Monthly data is reviewed annually and adjustments are made to prior monthly numbers going back up to two years. Occasionally as we saw in May there are adjustments made even more rarely than annually.

Weekly data are never adjusted after data is released. That is one reason why it is best to use monthly data. It is more consistent. The more important reason is that monthly supply data is actual data based on state by state reporting.

I personally donít believe it is worth spending much time analyzing the weekly data. I am using the weekly supply data, but just taking the data at face value as it comes off the report. I use it to update the trend since the last monthly report two months earlier.

Analyzing weekly adjustments would be subject to more error than the model driven production number taken at face value. It may be useful for purveyors of analysis to use weekly adjustments to drive home the point that weekly data should not be trusted, but the value in forecasting is very limited. Itís a better trade off to use the accuracy of monthly data rather than the freshness of weekly data.

Many people who read the EIA reports may not realize that the weekly or monthly adjustments donít make up any part of the published production numbers. They are in addition to the field production and import numbers. In fact the adjustments number could represent error in either field production, imports, exports, stocks change or refinery inputs. Itís just more likely the error is in either imports or field production. However the EIA leaves it to others to draw conclusions about where they originated. By making some realistic assumptions about the adjustment term it is possible to adjust field production to get a better picture of whatís really happening on a monthly basis.

Month after month, adjustments usually indicate some increase in field production. Sometimes minor, sometimes they are of larger size. Occasionally about once a year they can point to decreases in production, usually very modestly. Once in a great while as occurred in March they can have a more significant negative impact. This may happen about once every five years. Anyone saying adjustments can reduce production, except in very rare instances doesnít understand the methodology of how these EIA numbers are prepared.

Letís look at some numbers. In the last three months available, Feb Mar and Apr, field production was 9.432mm bbls/d, 9.692mm bbls/d and 9.701mm bbls/d. These numbers can be further refined by eliminating GOM and Alaska numbers, which contain no shale. After all what is important to most investors is forecasting what will happen with shale. The numbers net of the GOM and Alaska, those areas having no shale, are now 7.505mm bbls/d, 7.774mm bbls/d and 7.680mm bbls/d. These numbers reflect production in areas of the US that are primarily shale. There is what looks like a moderate size peak in March.

However we still have not dealt with the monthly adjustments. After applying my own allocation formula to the EIA monthly adjustments for the same three months I now show production of 7.612mm bbls/d, 7.636mm bbls/d and 7.793mm bbls/d mm for the three months ending in April. This shows a fairly steady increase through April.

Since the April report, May and June weekly production numbers indicate a drop from April to June of ~100,000 bbls/d. If these weekly numbers hold in the monthlies we can say a very moderate decline started in May. This outlook is likely more bullish than the market currently perceives. However based on the monthly numbers alone itís certainly possible we can see a leveling or even a slight increase. So overall its probably bullish.

Barry

Click To Add Your POPositive RecommendationITIVE Recommendation!   |  Currently: 
 94 positive

 << previous next >>

Looking for insight and analysis shared by fellow self directed investors? You've come to the right place! ValueForum is the web's best community forum for unvarnished, trusted, up-to-the-minute thinking on investments. What you just read is a "public post" but most posts including comments and replies, are available only to members.

Imagine walking into a secluded room where some of the smartest, most successful investors in America are gathered — self-directed investors and hedge fund managers alike — to share investing ideas.

In this private setting, members of this exclusive group are able to share honest opinions and unfiltered insights on stocks, bonds, ETFs, options, Forex and more. There's also a healthy amount of respectful debate as they bandy ideas about. And in the end, everyone is the richer for it.

That kind of exchange is exactly what happens every day here on ValueForum.com, the Internet's premier investing community.

Membership in this private online community is strictly limited — just 1500 investors will be admitted — but today you are in line to be one of them.

Before I tell you about all the member benefits waiting for you, I want to make one thing clear: ValueForum.com is nothing like the big free public investment boards out there.

We started ValueForum.com so that serious investors could get away from the noise, the shills and the shouting that plague public stock message boards.

That's why our community is founded on a few simple rules that keep the quality of our content and our members very high...

  • Privacy is paramount and confidentiality strictly enforced. Members are forbidden from sharing or reposting any members-only ValueForum.com content; violators forfeit membership.

  • Multiple aliases are not permitted (behind every screen name is a member profile so you can get to know your fellow members — and many have become lifelong friends).

  • No unsolicited or unauthorized advertising or product selling is allowed.

  • Robust debates are encouraged, but respect and common courtesy are expected with fighting and name-calling disallowed.

  • Violators forfeit membership.

And it works. As one of our long-time members explains:

"ValueForum gives you the chance to learn from people who aren't trying to sell you anything, just willing to give away their sincere thoughts. I have made a lot of money from information on VF."

So whether you are looking for new stock ideas or new ways to boost your investment income with REITs, BDCs, high-yield bonds, closed-end funds, you'll be thrilled at the constant flow of reliable ideas and analysis.

As another of our members going by the handle of oldart will tell you...

"No friend, no book, no broker, no advisor, no expert has ever provided a tenth what I am able to find here. The best money I have EVER spent is for membership."

WHAT YOU GET

Your ValueForum.com membership gives you unlimited access to:

  • A steady stream of top-notch investment ideas.

  • Invaluable insights and analysis on stocks, bonds, REITs, BDCs, and more.

  • Over 100 message board topics to help you focus on the areas that interest you most.

  • The chance to share your investment ideas and have them thoroughly vetted by your ValueForum peers before you make a move.

  • The ValueForum.com stock rating system with more than 1,000 rated stocks.

And yet another member (known on ValueForum as "beetlebomb") tells all willing to listen:
"The cost of ValueForum is a pittance compared to the benefits you will receive. If you are a serious investor who is tired of being fleeced by the Wall Street crowd, I highly recommend you join VF on a trial basis and experience its benefits first hand."

The best way to see what ValueForum.com can do for you is to let you take it for a test drive.

That's why we're offering a special one week "guest pass" that lets you experience the full force of ValueForum.com for just $7.

$7 for access to a new investing tool that can be truly life changing. It was for this member, who goes by "stlbeerman"

" VF has really changed my life and made me more wealthy than I ever expected."

It's lively and engaging, but like Las Vegas, what goes on inside ValueForum stays inside ValueForum — the public post you just read is the exception, not the norm. See for yourself before our remaining memberships are claimed and it's too late!

You can get started now with your seven day guest pass (just $7) if you'd like, or, grab a 3, 6, or 12 month pass here.

Get Started Now image

"Value Forum is literally the best web site on the Internet for investors bar none. It's a real time collection of news, experiences, data sharing, opinions that you can never get from bigger sites like TheStreet.com or Motley Fool. It allows you to gather multiple opinions you can never get from speaking to a stock broker or their analysts."
--bonddadddy

As seen in:



Ranked: Forbes best of the web

"Best investment I ever made."
--PhillyJoe

"I have made a lot of money from ideas exchanged on this forum. I would recommend VF to any serious investor, and I will never be without it."
--tankerat

Try It Now image

"Unbelievably board and deep industry knowledge."
--MtnTopTradr

"Our retirement has been a financial success due entirely to Value Forum."
--newby

"The very best investing board in the country whether your profile is high risk/high reward all the way to conservative/adverse to risk & volatility. This is a monitored board where civility & helpfulness rule."
--ronstaug

Start your test drive image



Email / About | Privacy | Terms of Use | How To / FAQ | Msg Ticker | VF Home | My.vf | BDCs.vf | Energy.vf | REITs.vf | TA.vf
 
Nothing in ValueForum.com is intended to be investment advice, nor does it represent the opinion of, counsel
from, or recommendations by ValueForum.com. ©2003 - 2017, Powered in part by Ticker TechnologiesContact Us

Understanding EIA Data and How to Use It Now